N
The Global Insight

Is a 2005 buffalo nickel rare?

Author

Michael Gray

Updated on April 10, 2026

The October auction broke the record for highest price, but you can find these rare coins listed on eBay for even more. The lower priced listings are still going for $300, $400, up to $800, and more. PCGS explains that this nickel started earning way more than five cents soon after the mistake was discovered in 2005.

Is a 2005 nickel with a buffalo on it worth anything?

2005-D Jefferson Bison value is from 5 cents to . 10 cents in grades almost uncirculated (AU) or less, and . 50 cents plus for uncirculated raw examples.

Did they make buffalo nickels in 2005?

The 2005 Buffalo Nickel was made for only a few months in early 2005, then the mintage stopped forever. No more of these coins will ever be made, therefore ensuring their scarcity and collector value into the future.

Is a 2005 Buffalo nickel worth more than 5 cents?

Unless there is an unusual error, it is worth five cents, like any other nickel. One unusual error has been found. The left rear leg is detached from the buffalo’s body, as you see here: Initially, the detached leg error was expected to be rare and very valuable. However, it turns out to be a very common error.

When did they stop making the Buffalo nickel?

The Buffalo nickel ceased production in 1938, being replaced by the Jefferson nickel. There was a 2006 one ounce gold bullion coin produced that is worth about $5000.

Is the D Buffalo nickel worth the same?

Not all variations are worth the same. Only in Denver was the error made that triggers the price of the currency. The name of the error is Speared Bison, and as the name says, these are marks that appear to pierce like spears through the American bison on the reverse.

What are the different types of Buffalo nickels called?

This series of four different nickels is called The Westward Journey Nickels. It is precisely in 2005 that the old buffaloes that we have not seen since 1938 reappeared.